Suggested readings (in chronological
order)
Pauline Bart. "Depression in middle-aged women." In
Women in a sexist society. (Eds) Vivian Gornick and Barbara Moran.
New York: Basic Books, 1971.
Diane Scully and Pauline Bart. A funny thing happened on the
way to the orifice: Women in gynecology textbooks. American Journal
of Sociology. 1973; 78: 1045.
Rosetta Reitz. Menopause: A positive approach. Pennsylvania:
Chilton Book Company. 1977.
Barbara Ehrenreich and D English. For her own good: 150 years
of experts' advice to women. London: Pluto Press. 1979
Lois Verbrugge and R Steiner. Physician treatment of men and
women patients: Sex bias or appropriate care? Medical Care 1981;
19: 609-32.
FB McCrea. The politics of menopause: the discovery of a deficiency
disease. Social Problems 1983; 31: 111-23.
S Bell. Changing ideas: The medicalization of menopause. Social
Science and Medicine. 1987; 24: 535-42.
Nancy Worcester and Marianne Whatley. The selling of HRT: Playing
on the fear factor. Feminist Review. 1992; 41: 1-26.
Margaret Lock. The politics of midlife and menopause: ideologies
for the second sex in North America and Japan In: Lindenbaum
S, Lock M (eds) Knowledge, power, and practice: the anthropology
of medicine and everyday life. Berkeley, CA. University of California
Press, 1993; 330-63.
K MacPherson. False promises of hormone replacement therapy and
current dilemmas. In Callahan JC (ed) Menopause: a midlife
passage. Indianapolis, IN: Indiana University Press 1993;
145-59.
Jerilynn C. Prior One voice on menopause. J Am Med Women's
Assoc. Jan/Feb 1994.
Sandra Coney. The menopause industry: How the medical establishment
exploits women. First published by Penguin Books (NZ) Ltd,
1991. In 1993, it was published in Australia by Spinifex Press
Pty Ltd. The first U.S. edition (revised) was published by Hunter
Press Inc. 1994. The forward is written by Barbara Seaman, best
known for her book, Women and the crisis in sex hormones first
published in 1977. Seaman relates the difficulty that Coney had
in getting this book published by a U.S. press.
ERT: The production of medical knowledge In Women, Health and
Healing Levin. (will fill in the author & date later)
Renate Klein and Lynette Dumble. Disempowering midlife women:
The science and politics of hormone replacement therapy (HRT).
Women's Studies International forum 1994; 17: 327-43.
Terri Apter. Secret paths: Women in the new midlife. WW Norton
& Co. New York, 1995. Highly recommended! In her extensive
study of midlife women, Terri feels that the changes that occur
during the midlife of women, becoming more energetic, assertive
and self-confident, is not due to the biological changes at menopause
but rather to psychological development.
For two articles debating the risk vs benefits of hormones:
Controversies in Science: Janet L. Stanford. The benefits of
hormone replacement therapy outweigh the breast-cancer risks
for some women. And, Graham A. Colditz, The benefits of hormone
replacement therapy do not outweigh the increased risk of breast
cancer. Both in The Journal of NIH Research, April 1996
Susan Love. Dr. Susan Love's hormone book: Making informed choices
about menopause. New York: Random House 1997.
Paula Brown Doress and Diana Lakin Siegal. Ourselves growing
older: Women aging with knowledge and power. Simon and Schuster.
1997.
Nina Shandler. Estrogen: The natural way. Villard, New York.
1997. This book has great recipes for soy and flax seed. One
complaint though, I think her statement "After the age of
55, women are ten times more likely to have a heart attack than
before menopause." (page xxvii) is very misleading. For
more on this, check "Heart disease mortality data and a
critique, USA" in the heart
disease section.
In 18-19 June 1997, an International Symposium "The Menopausal
Transition: a different view" was held at Leiden, The Netherlands,
. The proceedings of this conference have been published in the
Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynaecology 1997; 18,
Issue 2. The symposium was organized because of the concerns
about the medicalization of menopause and about the underestimation
of the consequences of long-term hormone treatment. Although
many of the participants at this symposium are physicians, all
are very critical of the medical perspective.
Eylard V. van Hall, professor of gynaecology at Leiden University
Medical Centre in The Netherlands and editor of this issue writes
in his editorial: "The use of the terms menopausal and postmenopausal
in this respect wrongly singles out women as potentially ill
(mentally and physically) by the mere fact that they reach menopause
and has therefore to be considered as an inappropriate, sexist
and agist medical misnomer."
Other articles in this issue:
Ingar Palmlund contributed two articles: "The social construction
of menopause as risk" and "The marketing of estrogens
for menopausal and postmenopausal women". She argues that
the USA may be a "home base" for some of the current
promotion of menopause as risk. She cites many examples from
the popular culture in the USA that seem intended to create a
"collective consciousness" that women over 40 need
medical and pharmaceutical treatment.
"The menopause and the pharmaceutical industry" by
MN Dukes. In this article, the techniques used to develop a large
market in estrogen for the long-term treatment of postmenopausal
women are discussed. They include the selective emphasis to physicians
of those research findings which point to the value of hormones,
the development of direct approaches to the public to stimulate
interest, and the creation of intermediary institutes to undertake
selective research and influence opinion.
You can read the abstracts to these articles on PUBMED
(for free). If you want to read an entire article but can't find
this journal at a medical library near you, it can be ordered
right on the PUBMED site (for a fee). Many of the above books
can be found at your local library or at a university library.
If you are working to reclaim menopause, share the articles,
the books, and your knowledge with others.
|